A Huge Collaboration Gets an Equally Huge Reaction

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating7.5/10
I WAS NOT READY!! Falling In Reverse – Joseph Reaction (Reaction/Review)

Serj Tankian’s entrance becomes the defining moment for the host, who immediately connects the acoustic passage and vocal character to an older System of a Down sound. That response captures the approach taken throughout: rather than methodically dissecting “Joseph,” the reaction focuses on the moments that create the biggest immediate impact. The surprise works particularly well because the host says he initially expected something slower and more restrained before the song dramatically changed direction.

The collaboration itself receives most of the attention. Corey Taylor’s contribution is praised for its intensity, while Serj is described as delivering exactly the kind of appearance the host hoped to hear from him. Jason Richardson’s writing contribution also gets specific recognition, with the reaction pointing toward the riffs and heavier metalcore character he appears to bring to the track. Those observations give the commentary more substance than simply declaring that an impressive collection of musicians sounds good together.

The breakdowns and riffs generate some of the most animated responses, including an immediate replay of the breakdown. That spontaneity is effective for communicating just how strongly the music lands on first listen. There is a genuine sense that the host has been caught off guard by the escalation from the comparatively restrained opening into something much heavier, and that surprise gives the reaction its momentum.

Ronnie Radke and Falling in Reverse are also placed within a broader pattern of ambitious collaborations, with the host mentioning previous appearances involving Marilyn Manson, Jelly Roll, and Alex Terrible. The point is less about analyzing those earlier collaborations than emphasizing the scale of what the band is attempting here. The host briefly acknowledges that Radke can be divisive on social media, but deliberately separates that issue from his enthusiasm for the musical and visual execution on display.

The music video receives similarly enthusiastic treatment. The host highlights the plane sequence, fire, gun-heavy imagery, extensive effects, and laser-eye visuals, joking that the production seems to answer the question of how many effects it needs with “infinite.” It is a colorful description of the spectacle, although the commentary never develops into much analysis of how those images relate to the song, its story, or its themes. The cinematic excess is primarily appreciated as spectacle.

That distinction ultimately defines the reaction. Its excitement feels authentic, and the host identifies concrete musical elements behind that excitement, but virtually everything receives overwhelming praise. There is little examination of the songwriting, vocal interplay, structure, lyrics, or whether such an effects-heavy visual presentation ever becomes excessive. Even the closing admission that he does not know what to call one musical quality illustrates the limitations of the analysis: the enthusiasm is clear, but the vocabulary for explaining it sometimes runs out before the excitement does.

Pros

  • The host’s surprise at the song’s shift from a restrained opening into heavier material gives the reaction genuine energy.
  • Serj Tankian, Corey Taylor, and Jason Richardson’s contributions receive individual attention rather than being treated merely as famous names.
  • Replaying the breakdown effectively captures the spontaneous excitement of a first-listen reaction.
  • Specific references to riffs, acoustic elements, breakdowns, and the music video’s elaborate imagery keep the praise tied to recognizable features of the production.

Cons

  • Nearly uninterrupted enthusiasm leaves little room for critical examination of the song’s weaker or less successful elements.
  • The commentary says relatively little about the lyrics, songwriting structure, or how the featured performers function together beyond their immediate impact.
  • Discussion of the elaborate music video focuses on spectacle without exploring its narrative or thematic significance.
  • Some musical observations remain vague despite the host’s strong reaction, limiting the depth of the review component.

The infectious excitement makes this an entertaining first-listen companion, particularly when the featured performers and heavier transitions arrive. Its musical observations provide some useful specificity, but the overwhelmingly celebratory approach keeps it closer to an enthusiastic fan reaction than a detailed critical review.

Related Reviews