Brianna has a question when she pulls duct tape out of the blue haul at Dollar Tree. What exactly did either shopper think a baby was going to do with it? That moment captures what makes Preston and Chase’s competition funny. Finding something in the right color is easy enough. Explaining why it belongs anywhere near a nursery takes more imagination.
The rules give the shopping a clear rhythm. Preston and Chase get 30 minutes at each store, with budgets rising from $50 at Dollar Tree to $100 at Five Below and $500 at Walmart. At Five Below, Chase checks out at $98.56 while Preston has to leave some of his finds behind. By Walmart, the bigger store and the scramble to reach the baby clothes section make the clock feel more consequential than the spending limit.
Preston’s determination to win as a dad before his child is even born gives Chase an opening to campaign for the name Chase Jr. Their teasing makes the aisle searches livelier, especially when the recurring duck purchases become enough of a problem for Preston to declare a ban at Walmart. Some of the other tangents wear out their welcome. The repeated requests for strangers to guess whether the baby is a boy or a girl yield much the same exchange, and Preston’s tour of his own toys turns part of the final round into a sales pitch.
Brianna brings a sharper eye to the hauls than either shopper seems to expect. She awards the first round to red because a baby toothbrush and diaper rash cream suggest somebody gave the baby’s needs some thought. At Five Below, she likes the purple blanket and light but openly questions who would buy Nightmare Critters for a nursery. Her reactions give the judging a point of view, even when the item-by-item format means sitting through several novelty purchases to get to one she has something interesting to say about.
The Walmart round pays off with two very different gifts. Brianna immediately sees a use for the pink diaper bag because she doesn’t have one yet, but it’s the ride-on car that wins her vote. Her story about wanting a Barbie Jeep as a kid explains how Chase takes the deciding round with a gift whose appeal has more to do with her own childhood than with anything the baby needs right away.
The announcement gives that choice a good punch line. The couple reveals they’re expecting a boy just after Brianna has picked the pink haul, and her insistence that she’s keeping the gifts is funnier than the earlier speculation about who can use which color. The repeated suggestion that pink purchases would be wasted on a boy feels particularly flimsy after watching her claim the car for reasons that were hers all along.
Pros
- The fixed timer and rising budgets give each store a different kind of pressure.
- Preston and Chase turn their rivalry into a running joke with the proposed baby name and the growing collection of ducks.
- Brianna explains her picks through specific reactions to practical items and novelty toys.
- The ride-on car earns its place in the finale through Brianna’s childhood story.
- The baby announcement lands as a comic reversal immediately after the winning haul is chosen.
Cons
- The repeated predictions from shoppers interrupt the hunt without adding much variety.
- Preston’s merchandise pitch stalls the Walmart round after the clock has already started.
- The item-by-item judging lingers on novelty purchases that draw nearly identical reactions.
- The recurring assumption that pink gifts are only useful for a girl makes some of the banter feel narrow.
The shopping game is at its best when a gift tells Brianna something about the person who bought it or reminds her of something she wanted herself. A tighter trip through the aisles would give those moments more room, but the deciding gift and the family announcement make for a warm finish.


