A Wild Cartoon Speed Race Where the Joke Matters More Than the Math

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating7.3/10
WHICH CARTOON WILL WIN?

A stolen bite of a burger provides the wonderfully flimsy excuse for assembling an enormous collection of animated characters and determining which one is supposedly the fastest. Snowy and Tyler turn the mystery into a race that begins with Cartman and steadily escalates through characters including SpongeBob, Bugs Bunny, Mario, Goku, Sonic, Superman and the Flash. It is an uncomplicated setup, but it gives the rapid-fire parade of familiar faces enough of a narrative thread to keep the competition moving.

Much of the entertainment comes from the hosts finding a joke for nearly every entrant. Homer Simpson is motivated by donuts, Garfield is chasing lasagna, Mr. Krabs wants money, and Courage is apparently fleeing something frightening. The observations are intentionally silly rather than analytical, and the constant banter gives the sequence the breathless energy of two people reacting to an increasingly ridiculous race. There is also some amusing use of established character dynamics, such as Jerry outrunning Tom and the Road Runner leaving Wile E. Coyote behind.

The escalating scale is the smartest structural choice. Ordinary runners eventually give way to vehicles, superheroes and characters supposedly moving at or beyond the speed of light. Metro Man, the Powerpuff Girls, Superman, Flash and Silver Surfer push the competition into increasingly absurd territory before teleportation and reality manipulation make the idea of a conventional footrace essentially meaningless. That progression prevents the lengthy procession of characters from feeling completely flat, because viewers are continually encouraged to wonder what could possibly surpass the latest contender.

As an actual comparison of fictional speed, however, the presentation is far less convincing. The hosts eventually claim that the speed figures were determined by “cartoon experts” analyzing source material, but no experts, methodology, calculations or specific supporting evidence are provided. Statements involving characters traveling thousands or billions of times the speed of light therefore function as assertions within the entertainment rather than demonstrated measurements. The later “beyond reality” section even acknowledges some of these problems, noting that reality manipulation, time control or teleportation does not necessarily establish infinite running speed.

There are other inconsistencies that make the rankings difficult to take literally. Characters are compared across completely different fictional universes with different rules, while running, flying, teleportation, vehicles and supernatural abilities are effectively treated as versions of the same thing. The Road Runner's speed is acknowledged as potentially changing according to the joke or scene, which points toward a larger problem with trying to assign definitive numbers to cartoon feats. Patrick's pet rock ultimately winning because it reaches the finish line without moving makes clear that comedy, not rigorous comparison, is the real destination.

Snowy and Tyler maintain considerable energy throughout, but the presentation can become exhausting. Nearly every new character produces another exclamation, superlative or quick gag, leaving little breathing room between reveals. Calls for likes, comments and subscriptions also repeatedly interrupt the race, culminating in the hosts joking that their own speed increases according to how quickly viewers subscribe. That fits the deliberately hyperactive style, although trimming some of those interruptions would make the central competition flow more smoothly.

Pros

  • The burger mystery provides a simple narrative hook that gives the enormous character race a clear purpose.
  • A huge range of recognizable animated characters creates plenty of opportunities for surprises, jokes and comparisons.
  • The steadily escalating speeds give the competition momentum as it moves from ordinary characters to superheroes, teleportation and reality-warping abilities.
  • Running jokes involving characters such as Homer, Garfield, Jerry and the Road Runner make effective use of familiar personality traits and rivalries.
  • Patrick's motionless pet rock provides a suitably absurd final punchline to the entire premise.

Cons

  • Extraordinary speed figures and rankings are presented without enough supporting evidence or methodology to make the comparison credible as analysis.
  • Running, flying, teleportation, vehicles, time manipulation and reality alteration are mixed together despite representing fundamentally different abilities.
  • Constant exclamations and superlatives make the commentary repetitive as the race progresses.
  • Frequent prompts for likes, comments and subscriptions interrupt the momentum of the competition.
  • The sheer number of characters leaves most entrants with only a brief joke or observation rather than a meaningful comparison.

The escalating parade of cartoon characters succeeds best as a fast, deliberately ridiculous guessing game rather than a serious attempt to establish fictional speed rankings. Its energetic banter, huge roster and increasingly absurd finale provide plenty of lightweight entertainment, although unsupported numbers and inconsistent comparison rules undermine the analytical premise. Patrick's pet rock winning without moving is ultimately the perfect indication of where the video's priorities lie.

Related Reviews