Michael has owned Raymond Hall’s three-color pentomino puzzle for years without looking at the arrangement it came in. He wants to solve it without remembering where even one piece goes, so he turns it toward the camera with his eyes shut while Hannah pretends she’s about to give away a placement. The gag doubles as a clear introduction to the puzzle. Hannah describes the five-square pieces and works out that the colors impose a second constraint on how they fit together. Her suggestion that Michael simply empty the pieces into a bag is funnier for how long he’s kept the puzzle face down.
The vial of “Comet Vomit” gives Michael’s confidence in his own memory a neat test. He opened one vial for another show and now can’t recall what it smelled like, which makes his certainty that a glimpse of the puzzle would stick with him all the more entertaining. His late clarification narrows the product’s premise to an approximation of detectable odors associated with a comet’s tail. The initial account of how researchers sampled the material stays vague, so the exchange works better as a story about the collectible than as an explanation of the science behind it.
The can from Wet Hot American Summer raises the stakes because opening it would alter the only screen-used movie prop Michael says he owns. His memory of discovering the film while home sick gives his refusal some feeling, and Hannah’s inspection earns a payoff when they spot a hole in the can. Their guesses about what happened inside remain guesses. The bit runs long once they start bargaining over how many YouTube likes it would take for Michael to eat the contents, especially after the discovery has already given the scene a good ending.
Hannah’s bottle of rum, saved since her 21st birthday for her 50th, brings the conversation somewhere more personal. She’s candid about how her idea of a good bottle has changed, which makes the promise to her younger self the interesting part of the story. Michael picks up on the difference between an object waiting for a date and his own possessions, which could sit untouched indefinitely. That exchange gives the opening premise more depth than another oddity would have.
A listener’s account of waking from surgery with apparent recall of an entire movie leads to a more uneven discussion. Both hosts question how much dialogue she could actually reproduce, and the reported case of a Dutch teenager temporarily speaking English after surgery gives them a concrete example involving a language he already knew. Those distinctions help keep the anecdote in proportion. The explanation gets much looser when Hannah likens deep anesthesia to death and invokes a numbered brain-monitor scale without explaining what it measures or what the numbers can establish.
The final listener question, about designs that have endured for millennia, gets an imaginative answer in the humble container. Ursula K. Le Guin’s carrier bag essay and Michael’s recollection of Marilyn French lead to a concrete idea about carrying home more food than you can hold in your hands. Michael also recognizes that perishable materials make the earliest containers difficult to trace. The leap from carrying surplus food to the emergence of laws, currency, and social hierarchies goes by too quickly for viewers to tell where the literary argument ends and the historical evidence begins.
Pros
- Hannah’s description makes the puzzle’s shape and color constraints easy to follow even on audio.
- The forgotten comet scent gives the conversation a funny reversal of Michael’s concern about remembering the puzzle.
- The story of discovering Wet Hot American Summer makes Michael’s attachment to the prop understandable.
- Hannah’s birthday rum gives the two hosts a more personal way to explore why people save things.
- The anesthesia discussion questions the listener’s reported recall and gives a specific case involving knowledge acquired before surgery.
Cons
- The comet segment gives a vague account of how the material behind the fragrance was sampled.
- The bargaining over YouTube likes prolongs the can segment after the hole provides its best reveal.
- The comparison between deep anesthesia and death leans on monitoring numbers the discussion barely explains.
- The container discussion draws sweeping conclusions about early society from a lightly sketched account of food gathering and storage.
Michael and Hannah are at their best when a small discovery changes the direction of their conversation. Their curiosity makes for an engaging show, though the scientific and historical detours need more of the care they bring to examining the objects in front of them.












