Returning to the strange train journey after the earlier demo gives the group an immediate objective: get beyond the point where their first attempt abruptly ended and finally discover what the expanded game contains. That continuity works particularly well because they remember just enough about old locations, enemies, and puzzles to recognize them while still being surprised by much of what happens. The result feels less like a conventional playthrough and more like four friends stumbling back into a shared nightmare they only partially remember.
Comedy dominates almost every interaction. The players hit each other, abandon teammates, argue about items, repeatedly derail serious moments with jokes, and turn even basic mechanics into extended bits. A horse transformation becomes a running source of ridicule, while rocks, bats, dynamite, guns, dancing, gambling, and even a misplaced plank generate their own miniature disasters. Much of the entertainment comes from how quickly an ordinary objective can collapse once somebody decides annoying the others is more interesting than completing it efficiently.
The game itself provides plenty of material for that chaos. Number puzzles, hostile creatures, spikes, moving hazards, keys, colored levers, records, melodies, mazes, caves, and environmental obstacles continually change what the group is being asked to do. Several cooperative sequences are particularly effective, including coordinating switches, navigating dangerous rooms, collecting keys while enemies patrol nearby, and figuring out how musical records fit into a larger puzzle. The progression rarely stays on one mechanic long enough to become completely routine.
There is also a surprisingly effective horror atmosphere underneath the jokes. Whispering voices, eyeballs, unsettling enemies, dark forests, caves, oversized creatures, and sudden attacks give the players genuine reasons to hesitate before exploring. The later choice between a seemingly pleasant route and a threatening “murder” cave captures the group's relationship with the game perfectly: obvious danger becomes more attractive precisely because it promises something ridiculous. Moments when everyone briefly stops joking to react to a disturbing environment help the horror imagery register before the comedy takes over again.
That constant joking is simultaneously the playthrough's biggest strength and its main limitation. Conversations regularly overlap, important instructions disappear beneath shouting, and potentially interesting discoveries can become difficult to follow because someone is already starting another bit. Progress sometimes stalls because teammates are attacking each other, wandering away, gambling items, or deliberately causing trouble. Viewers primarily interested in understanding the puzzles or seeing an efficient run may find the disorder exhausting, especially during sections where several people are speaking at once.
Still, the group's chemistry keeps the disorder from feeling entirely arbitrary. Teammates repeatedly rescue one another, communicate solutions, improvise plans, and occasionally demonstrate surprisingly effective cooperation before immediately undermining it for a joke. The expanded game also gives them enough new territory that the return feels justified rather than like a simple replay of the demo. By ending after roughly half of the available journey, however, the playthrough once again stops without providing the full resolution that returning viewers may have been hoping to see.
Pros
- Strong group chemistry turns routine exploration and puzzle solving into consistently unpredictable comedy.
- The expanded game introduces a varied mix of puzzles, hazards, enemies, environmental challenges, and cooperative mechanics.
- Creepy forests, caves, creatures, whispers, and surreal imagery create an effective horror backdrop beneath the humor.
- Callbacks to the earlier demo give the return a useful sense of continuity while leaving substantial new material to discover.
- Several cooperative challenges produce entertaining moments of genuine teamwork amid the deliberate sabotage.
Cons
- Frequent overlapping dialogue and shouting can make instructions, puzzle solutions, and individual reactions difficult to follow.
- Extended bits, friendly attacks, wandering, and deliberate sabotage occasionally slow the actual progression considerably.
- Some jokes are repeated long after their initial payoff, adding to the already hectic presentation.
- Covering only about half of the expanded game leaves the larger journey unresolved.
A much larger version of the cursed train adventure gives this group exactly the kind of unpredictable playground that suits their chaotic chemistry. The constant interruptions can overwhelm the game's puzzles and horror elements, but the combination of cooperative problem-solving, deliberate sabotage, bizarre discoveries, and genuine scares makes the return consistently entertaining.


