Farm Chores Turns Relentless Flirting Into a Surprisingly Personal Conversation

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating7.8/10
Colton Underwood Had Matt Mathews Speaking in Tongues | Farm Chores

Colton Underwood arrives ready to shovel manure, handle horses, and give Matt Mathews almost as much trouble as the animals do. Their existing friendship immediately gives the conversation a loose, combative rhythm, with Mathews repeatedly insisting that Underwood is unattractive while Underwood keeps finding ways to turn the insults into flirtation. That running joke becomes the episode’s comic backbone, particularly because both men are clearly willing to keep escalating it rather than retreat into a conventional celebrity interview.

The early discussion about Underwood coming out gives the chaos some substance. He says he knew he was different from a young age, describes recognizing his attraction to men during puberty, and talks about trying to navigate those feelings while playing football and eventually appearing on The Bachelor. Mathews responds with his own experiences involving sexuality and religion, but the exchange never becomes solemn for long. Crude jokes arrive almost immediately after vulnerable admissions, creating a tone that is unusually candid but deliberately incapable of staying serious.

That approach works because Underwood understands Mathews’ style and pushes back rather than functioning as a passive interview subject. The repeated argument over whether Mathews is attractive, Underwood’s comments about his husband, and their increasingly ridiculous innuendo make the interaction feel genuinely reciprocal. At times, however, the same joke is stretched well beyond its natural endpoint. Mathews repeatedly returns to Underwood supposedly calling him ugly, while references to their marriages and mutual attraction become so frequent that later variations add little.

The actual farm chores provide useful physical structure between conversations. Horses refusing to enter the correct stalls create some of the funniest unscripted complications, especially as Underwood’s gentler handling contrasts with Mathews’ much louder approach. Feeding animals, collecting eggs, chasing chickens, searching for missing cows, and eventually using the four-wheeler keep the pair moving through different situations. Underwood also participates more enthusiastically than the premise requires, and Mathews ultimately acknowledges that he does more work than most guests.

A lengthy conversation about Underwood and his husband building their family becomes the most informative portion. Underwood describes fertility problems he attributes to habits including hot tubs, saunas, exercise, and tight clothing, then explains sperm freezing, egg donation, embryo creation, and surrogacy. These are his descriptions of his own fertility experience rather than general medical guidance, and the segment is strongest when it stays focused on that personal process. Mathews’ shock at the roughly $300,000 cost produces an effective comic reaction, although the repeated jokes about obtaining a baby from a person with a drug addiction are pushed so aggressively that they begin to crowd out Underwood’s explanation of an expensive and emotionally significant decision.

Parenthood provides another revealing contrast. Underwood discusses an audio memoir framed as a letter to his son and explains that he and his husband send their child monthly emails intended to be shared when he turns 18. Mathews predictably mocks the sentimentality, while Underwood calmly defends the idea as a way of documenting his son’s childhood and explaining who his father was and is. The disagreement is funny precisely because Underwood refuses to become defensive, allowing a sincere expression of parental affection to survive inside an otherwise relentlessly vulgar conversation.

By the end, the farm format has done what it is supposed to do: loosen the guest up while generating comedy from real tasks rather than relying entirely on seated conversation. The editing repeatedly returns to direct-to-camera remarks in which each man insults the other, but those interruptions also reveal genuine affection underneath the performance. Mathews ultimately admits that Underwood worked harder than most guests and might even be invited back, giving their mock hostility a satisfying payoff. The episode is far too repetitive and deliberately crude to suit every viewer, but the combination of chemistry, physical comedy, and unexpectedly open discussion keeps the extended banter from becoming entirely one-note.

Pros

  • Underwood and Mathews have strong enough chemistry to sustain an intentionally combative, flirtatious interview style.
  • Underwood speaks candidly about coming out, navigating his sexuality, marriage, fertility treatment, surrogacy, and fatherhood.
  • Horses, chickens, pigs, and missing cows give the conversation varied physical comedy rather than leaving the pair in a static interview setup.
  • Underwood actively participates in the chores and pushes back against Mathews’ jokes instead of merely reacting to them.
  • The discussion of monthly emails and the audio memoir provides a sincere look at how Underwood wants to communicate his life story to his son.
  • Direct-to-camera commentary effectively turns their supposed dislike of each other into an ongoing joke with a clear final payoff.

Cons

  • The recurring argument about Mathews being “ugly” and Underwood being attracted to him is repeated long after the joke has been established.
  • Constant sexual innuendo occasionally overwhelms more interesting discussions about identity, family, and parenthood.
  • The repeated jokes about acquiring a baby from someone with a drug addiction become excessive and distract from the surrogacy discussion.
  • Potentially useful fertility information remains anecdotal and tied specifically to Underwood’s reported experience rather than being explored with broader context.
  • Some farm sequences run on the same pattern of incorrect instructions, insults, and escalating profanity, making the middle portion feel repetitive.

Strong personal chemistry transforms routine farm work into a chaotic celebrity conversation that is frequently crude but also more revealing than its nonstop insults initially suggest. Repetition weakens several running jokes, yet Underwood’s willingness to discuss identity, family building, and fatherhood while fully participating in Mathews’ comic antagonism gives the episode both energy and unexpected warmth.

Related Reviews