Picket’s first spin asks three contestants to turn a Forsaken character into a kitten, and within one round the group has heard a pleading meow, an elaborately edited transformation, and a cat chasing a red dot into a pit of corruption. Each contestant gets 30 minutes to turn the same prompt into an ASMR skit, with up to five points apiece for humor, cringe, and effort. The setup makes every round a comparison, and the looming penalty of slipping ten unexplained meows into a future video gives the contestants something suitably ridiculous to lose.
The kitten round establishes how differently Corso, Sarzik, and Mikhail approach the assignment. Corso leans into the discomfort of the transformation, Sarzik draws praise for his editing and sound effects, and Mikhail gets a bigger laugh by giving the kitten a recognizable habit that leads straight to disaster. Having everyone mute during playback gives each entry a chance to land before the others weigh in. The reactions are also more revealing when someone stops laughing long enough to explain what worked.
The round about an overzealous Two-Time fan shows where the judging gets complicated. Mikhail’s parody of a fan taking a character ranking personally gets Picket laughing hard enough to award full marks for humor, but that same laughter leaves little room for cringe and keeps the total closer than the reaction suggests. Picket explains the discrepancy, which makes his thinking easy to follow. The separate deductions for including video and using uncredited thumbnail art are harder to anticipate from the three categories laid out at the start.
The generator breakup round gives the sound work its clearest showcase. Sarzik uses footsteps and changes in vocal distance to suggest movement, while Mikhail builds his scene around the sounds of the generator itself. Both approaches give the listener something to picture, even if the joke about a character’s devotion to generators takes longer to click for someone unfamiliar with Forsaken. The cooking round is easier to enter cold, especially when an earnest lasagna demonstration goes wrong and Sarzik makes the sound of a black hole into the payoff.
By the last round, the time limit has grown to 45 minutes and the skits are supposed to run for two minutes. Mikhail uses the extra room well, setting up a battlefield farewell before swerving into an embarrassingly petty confession. Corso’s entry keeps piling on bodily noises after the scene has made its point, and the group’s extended reactions can feel much the same. The running commentary is funniest when someone singles out a choice the audience can hear for themselves. A chorus of disbelief has diminishing returns.
Corso’s chance to escape the penalty with a perfect score gives the finale a clear target, and his 14.5 out of 15 makes for a genuine near miss. Sarzik’s final entry is largely withheld, leaving the audience to infer its effect from the others’ reactions and Picket’s exaggerated cringe score. That decision makes the entry difficult to judge alongside the other two at the moment when the contest is asking viewers to compare them most closely.
Pros
- The shared prompts give three different comic approaches room to emerge in each round.
- Muting the group during playback lets the skits establish their own timing.
- Sarzik’s use of footsteps and vocal distance gives the generator scene a sense of physical space.
- Mikhail’s battlefield skit gets a strong laugh by committing to the farewell before revealing the confession.
- Corso’s shot at a perfect score gives the final round a concrete stake and a close finish.
Cons
- Some prompts rely on Forsaken terminology and character habits that the group barely explains.
- Point deductions for video and uncredited artwork introduce criteria outside the opening rundown.
- Repeated bodily noises and prolonged reactions wear down the timing of several late jokes.
- Withholding most of Sarzik’s final skit leaves viewers with little basis for comparing it with the other entries.
The contest is at its funniest when a bizarre prompt pushes someone to build a scene with its own comic logic. The group’s willingness to embarrass themselves makes the format work, even when their enthusiasm for a gag outlasts its payoff.

