Jane Remover on Catchy Songs, Restless Fans, and the Live Exhibit

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating8.4/10
A PERFECT INTERVIEW WITH JANE REMOVER

Jane Remover pictured themself suspended in liquid because “Beauty Sleep” sounded aquatic and dreamy to them. Anthony Fantano asks what the tank symbolizes, and Jane starts with a detail no amount of interpretation would have turned up. Their freshly dyed hair bled into the blue water and changed its color. The exchange gets from a practical accident to Jane’s idea of the single as an awakening after a period of incubation, giving the conversation about their next album something concrete to build on.

Fantano follows Jane’s decisions closely enough to catch an apparent contradiction. If they thought the songs on the heart EP could hold up for years, why put them out on impulse? Jane remembers hearing “So What” on a flight, wanting to finish it as soon as they got home, and getting the only reassurance they needed from their sister. That story gives some weight to the later admission that they enjoy making listeners wait for a release. The interview spends less productive time guessing letters in the next album’s working title, a bit that goes on well past the first few wrong guesses.

The return to Frailty makes good use of Fantano’s history with Jane’s music. Revisiting the album for its anniversary reissue takes Jane back to the summer they made it at 17, and they can hear both the honesty of the writing and the roughness of the production. Fantano also asks whether Jane thinks he got his Census Designated review wrong. His relief at the answer gives the conversation a slightly self-serving turn, but Jane’s distinction between a considered negative review and a one-line dismissal gives the exchange a reason to be there.

“Live Exhibit” sounds like playful tour branding until Jane explains why they can feel like a painting at one moment and a zoo animal the next. Fantano asks how that squares with their account of fans being kind in public, drawing out the difference between a friendly encounter on the street and a room full of people raising their phones at the same moment. A later story about Danny Brown encouraging Jane to keep touring the record adds a practical reason for the new dates. Jane wanted to hear what those songs could do in front of a crowd big enough to match their energy.

The discussion of genre gets livelier when Jane calls making a conventional-sounding record an experiment in itself. Their memories of Top 40 radio and Black Eyed Peas CDs in the car make that answer feel like a genuine creative ambition. It also complicates Fantano’s account of an artist who can draw listeners from hyperpop, underground rap, and rock. He knows those audiences well enough to ask what happens when fans arrive wanting more of one specific sound, although he moves through some of the scene references quickly enough to leave newcomers catching up.

The loose format pays off when a rapid-fire question about advice from another artist turns into the Danny Brown story, and the Pokémon exchange is funny because Fantano keeps asking Jane to explain their strategy. The same format gives a stray question about Billy Corgan room to run even after Jane says they had never heard about the marriage. By the time Fantano circles back to the lyrics of “Beauty Sleep,” Jane has a funny story about a fan unwittingly standing next to the person referenced in a different song. It’s a good anecdote that leaves the single’s own writing only briefly explored.

Pros

  • The opening discussion connects the sound of “Beauty Sleep” to the physical choices behind its video.
  • Fantano’s follow-up on the heart EP gets Jane to explain what makes them release one project on impulse and hold another back.
  • The Frailty reissue gives Jane a concrete reason to revisit the writing and production choices they made at 17.
  • The conversation about public recognition draws out how differently Jane experiences attention on the street and onstage.
  • Jane’s Top 40 memories give their interest in making a straightforward pop record a personal history.
  • The Danny Brown anecdote explains why Jane wanted to give the previous album another run of live shows.

Cons

  • The working-title guessing game takes up several exchanges while revealing little about the next album.
  • Some of the discussion of genre crossover assumes familiarity with the artists and scenes Fantano mentions.
  • The sponsor read breaks the momentum between the conversation about criticism and the discussion of touring.
  • The rapid-fire segment gives tangents such as the Billy Corgan question more time than their answers warrant.
  • The late return to “Beauty Sleep” leaves its lyrics largely unexplored.

Fantano and Jane Remover have enough history for a question about an old review to feel as candid as a joke about their birthdays. The conversation could use some trimming, but its best exchanges let Jane surprise Fantano and revise the premise of his question. That makes it a revealing interview about an artist whose audience keeps growing faster than any one description of their music can keep up.

Recent Reviews