John Mulaney starts his seventh turn as an SNL host by remembering how much easier the show would have been to write without a host. His solution is to take the job himself and declare it effectively vacant. The joke gets the obligatory homecoming out of the way quickly, and his observation that New York is dark at lunchtime gives the opening a more immediate sense of place than another round of thanks would have.
The first sustained bit begins with Mulaney’s comic theory that his father is autistic. The richest material comes from the tiny decisions he remembers, like his father shaking a baby’s hand or trying to start a conversation with a four-year-old by remarking on the volume of trash in his room. Mulaney makes the garbage-can line do double duty when it turns up again in an imagined corporate takeover. The same halting attempt at small talk sounds almost considerate in the first scene and wonderfully ill-timed in the second.
Mulaney gets some mileage from the idea that older generations had their own ways of describing traits they might understand differently today. His father’s supposed diagnosis is a family conjecture played for laughs, and the move from specific memories to Eagle Scouts, butterfly collectors, and a grandfather who avoids talking about the war reduces several kinds of behavior to the same shorthand. The premise has more comic range when Mulaney can show how one person speaks and thinks.
The baby-boomer rebuttal gives him a cleaner structure. Each familiar charge against Gen Z gets an older counterpart, and the account of three of his mother’s friends being banned from Facebook Marketplace is the sharpest reversal because the dispute escalates over furniture that was being given away. The Thanksgiving routine has a similarly good ear for grievance, especially when his imagined mother admits she wants the chance to snub a significant other in her toast. The Wesleyan insult is blunter than the family impressions around it.
Mulaney calls his pivot to parenthood a bad transition, and the acknowledgment earns a laugh while leaving the seam visible. The scratchy-voiced preschooler quickly supplies a better connection through sound. A request for water balloons becomes a series of questions about how a child could have acquired the voice of a much older man, then the voice itself gives away where the bit is headed. By the time Mulaney introduces his health secretary, the impression has already made the introduction.
The Kennedy material is liveliest when Mulaney gives the character something absurd to say, like a claim about telekinesis supposedly backed by pamphlets in a rental car. His stories about performing at Riverkeeper benefits supply a personal angle, though the aside about Kennedy joining environmental cases late is a broad allegation delivered without a specific example. The closing voicemail gets back to firmer comic ground. Hearing Mulaney mistake Kennedy’s greeting for a call from the mother in The Goonies gives the impression one last reason to be there.
Pros
- The opening turns Mulaney’s history as an SNL writer and host into a quick joke about the job he has come back to do.
- The garbage-can callback gives a small childhood memory a second life in an imagined corporate takeover.
- The Facebook Marketplace story makes the generational reversal more specific with each new detail.
- The hoarse preschooler gives the Kennedy impression a recognizable voice before Mulaney identifies the character.
- The voicemail anecdote ends the political stretch on a compact punch line that depends on the impression.
Cons
- The autism premise grows reductive when hobbies, mannerisms, and a veteran’s silence all serve as interchangeable evidence for the joke.
- The Wesleyan insult is a coarser jab than the specific family behavior that makes the Thanksgiving routine funny.
- The shift into the toddler material feels abrupt even after Mulaney draws a laugh by pointing it out.
- The claim about Kennedy joining environmental cases late gets no concrete example and briefly stalls the routine.
Mulaney is funniest when he lets a person’s voice and choice of words carry the joke. The set sometimes trades that precision for a broad generational jab or a political aside, but it finds its footing again whenever he has a scene to play. The closing voicemail is a satisfying finish because the audience has spent the last stretch learning exactly how to hear it.











