Mythical Kitchen Puts the Thanksgiving Sides on Two Grocery Budgets

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating8.2/10
Dollar Tree vs. Costco Thanksgiving Challenge

Josh boils fresh Costco green beans until they’re floppy because the texture he wants is the one he remembers from a can. That choice gets at what makes this Mythical Kitchen challenge fun. Thanksgiving is a meal where a familiar flavor can count for as much as the quality of an ingredient, and giving sweet potato casserole, green bean casserole, and stuffing the whole show leaves room to find out which upgrades actually matter to the people eating them.

The sweet potato casseroles make the differences between the two grocery hauls easy to follow. Costco supplies fresh sweet potatoes and pecans, while Dollar Tree supplies sweet potatoes packed in syrup and peanuts. Josh prefers the texture of the freshly boiled pieces before baking, but he’s genuinely curious whether his fondness for peanuts will carry over to the finished crumble. That running commentary gives the eventual tasting more to work with than a simple preference for one plate.

The green bean round makes the clearest case for considering labor alongside price. The Dollar Tree casserole comes together quickly with canned beans and condensed soup, while the Costco version starts with beans Lily has sliced lengthwise and a mushroom sauce Josh makes from scratch. The stuffing offers a different lesson. Josh likes the chicken flavor of Dollar Tree’s stock, and the frozen peppers and onions give that version a distinct flavor of its own. With the bread, sausage, and vegetables changing too, the stuffing is an interesting comparison of two recipes with several possible reasons for tasting different.

Josh is at his funniest when his digressions tell you something about the cook. His insistence that boxed stuffing is good enough for Michelin-starred chefs makes it easy to understand why he dehydrates bread and then tries to recapture a flavor he could get from a box. The long protein-bar sponsorship has less to do with the challenge and takes the show away from the casseroles just as the first pair goes into the oven.

Trevor correctly identifies the Dollar Tree plate and prefers the Costco spread, with the green bean casserole making the biggest difference for him. His reaction to the sweet potatoes is more unexpected. A side he usually passes up wins him over, and the Dollar Tree plate fares well enough that the reveal feels more like a judgment about particular dishes than a sweep. Trevor can see the color differences and notices a canned taste in the beans, so his successful guess tells us as much about recognizable ingredients as it does about flavor.

The closing price breakdown puts the preference in perspective. Josh reports spending $229 at Costco and $55 at Dollar Tree, then gives per-dish figures of $32 and $24, respectively. The per-dish comparison better reflects the bulk quantities in the Costco haul, though the episode leaves the calculation unexplained and acknowledges that the Costco membership is excluded. The figures give the tasting useful context, with some uncertainty about how closely another household could reproduce those costs.

Pros

  • Giving three familiar sides the full episode makes for a focused Thanksgiving challenge.
  • Josh’s early texture and flavor checks give viewers specific differences to look for in the finished dishes.
  • The two green bean preparations make the extra work of cooking from scratch easy to see.
  • The Dollar Tree chicken stock earns praise on its own merits and gives the cheaper haul a memorable win.
  • Trevor explains which dish most influenced his preference, giving the reveal more substance than a simple vote.

Cons

  • Several ingredients change at once in the stuffing, making it hard to tell which substitutions matter most.
  • The visible differences between the plates give Trevor clues before he has finished tasting.
  • The per-dish figures come without a calculation and exclude the Costco membership.
  • The extended protein-bar pitch interrupts the cooking after the sweet potato casseroles go into the oven.

The holiday table gives Josh a good reason to take canned ingredients seriously, and his affection for convenience food keeps the outcome from feeling predetermined. The challenge works best as a lively kitchen comparison with room for personal taste, especially when a familiar dish turns out to be worth a second bite.

Related Reviews