Ned Fulmer used to find a way to bring Ariel into almost any Try Guys segment, even when the subject was Fifty Shades of Grey. Years later, he opened his comeback podcast with Ariel sitting across from him as he admitted to cheating on her with a producer. Turkey Tom makes the connection between those appearances the center of his essay. The choice that gives the first episode of Rock Bottom its rawest exchange also brings Fulmer back to the relationship that had long given his work its commercial appeal.
The BuzzFeed history takes time to reach that point, but the early clips earn their place. They show a passing reference to Fulmer’s wife becoming a running joke the other Try Guys could play along with. After the group went independent, Baby Steps and The Date Night Cookbook turned the marriage into something the couple could build a business around. The progression is more persuasive than Tom’s suggestion that Fulmer needed to find a gimmick or risk being cut, a claim the early footage can do little to support.
Tom is especially clear about what changed when the Try Guys became business owners with employees of their own. The remaining members’ account of removing Fulmer from production and bringing in HR gives viewers a concrete response to compare with the Saturday Night Live sketch that treats the episode as fallout from a consensual kiss. The essay gets shakier when it reviews the online sleuthing. Tom acknowledges that the identity behind a key Reddit account was unconfirmed, yet gives allegations about company spending and hints of a cover-up more weight than his sourcing warrants.
The comeback section has better material to work with. Tom sets the impression of reconciliation left by Fulmer’s People interview alongside subsequent reporting that the couple had separated. He also follows the decision to turn the old Baby Steps channel into Rock Bottom, where Ariel’s questions give the premiere a candor its promotional rollout lacked. Fulmer’s later account that Ariel proposed the interview and had a stake in the show complicates Tom’s suggestion that she might have participated to make him look bad. Her reasons deserve more room than that speculation allows.
The reported drop from more than a million views for the premiere to 56,000 for the second episode gives Tom a concrete measure of how difficult it was to carry that initial attention into a regular interview show. Fulmer’s description at VidCon of the premiere as a strategic mistake fits uneasily with the podcast’s promise of personal reflection. Those examples support a critique of the rollout, but Tom lets them carry broader claims about the comeback’s durability and the authenticity of traffic on Fulmer’s main channel that the numbers alone cannot settle.
The charity walk is a revealing place to end. Fulmer says he has lived with multiple sclerosis since 2013 and presents the walk to Disneyland as a fundraiser and an awareness effort. The segment could have explored how a public scandal shapes the way viewers interpret work with a different purpose. Tom largely uses it to restate that viewers distrust Fulmer, while earlier jabs at his voice and dating profile make the essay feel increasingly invested in the ridicule it describes.
Pros
- Early Try Guys clips show how references to Ariel developed into a recognizable part of Fulmer’s onscreen identity.
- The parenting podcast and cookbook make the commercial role of the marriage easy to follow.
- The Try Guys’ statement and the Saturday Night Live sketch give viewers a clear comparison of how differently the workplace issue was framed.
- Ariel’s questions give the podcast premiere an emotional directness that the promotional interview lacks.
- The second episode’s reported view count gives the comeback analysis a concrete point of comparison beyond hostile comments.
Cons
- The discussion of alleged company spending and possible foreknowledge runs ahead of the evidence presented.
- Tom speculates about Ariel’s motives without giving enough weight to Fulmer’s account of her role in launching the podcast.
- The gap between views and engagement receives more weight than it can bear as evidence about traffic authenticity.
- Jokes about Fulmer’s voice and dating profile pull attention away from the more consequential choices behind the comeback.
Turkey Tom makes a persuasive case that the material chosen to relaunch Fulmer’s career kept audiences focused on the very history he was trying to move beyond. The essay is sharpest when it puts Fulmer’s public statements and production choices side by side, and less convincing when it reads a private motive into each decision.


