Patrick Stewart Through the Eyes of the People Who Worked With Him

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating8.2/10
“It’s the Captain”: Remembering Sir Patrick Stewart

When Patrick Stewart returned to the Enterprise bridge, one colleague remembers seeing some of his exhaustion lift. The carpet, the captain’s chair, and even the angle of the ramp had been recreated, yet Stewart thought the room felt smaller than he remembered. Those two recollections make an affectionate opening. The crew could rebuild the set to its original specifications, but what it felt like to step back onto it belonged to Stewart and the people who had worked there with him.

The casting stories give the conversation some welcome friction. One participant recalls Gene Roddenberry resisting the idea of a bald English captain and explains why he pushed for Stewart anyway, arguing that the part needed his gravitas. A story about a wig shipped from England supplies the comic payoff, while the first table read shows how quickly Stewart could leave his mark. As Brent Spiner remembers it, the way Stewart pronounced Data’s name settled the matter for everyone else.

The actors are especially interesting when they describe what Stewart brought to a scene. One longtime colleague compares working with him to playing tennis with a better player and recalls trusting what was happening between the actors even when directing from within the scene. Later, the group praises Stewart’s performance as a drunk while arguing over whether the scene in which Spiner’s character hits him with a car made sense. The disagreement gives the tribute some texture and shows how much these colleagues still care about the work.

The theater stories bring out a different side of Stewart’s authority. A jet-lagged attendee recalls falling asleep in the front row of Macbeth and waking to find Stewart looking straight at him and delivering his lines. The storyteller’s decision to leave at intermission gives the anecdote a better ending than any assessment of the production could. An account of Stewart joining an improvised Shakespeare show gives the group a chance to talk about his comic instincts, though the conversation moves on before it offers much sense of what he actually did onstage.

Stewart’s habit of bringing people together comes through in the recollection of a dinner he arranged at the Ivy, where Stephen Sondheim and Harold Pinter reportedly met for the first time. A smaller story says just as much about the friendships behind the tribute. When one participant’s young son answered the phone at dinner and announced that the captain was calling, the family already knew how long the conversation might last. Both stories benefit from details that only someone at the table would think to include.

The group’s familiarity makes for lively interruptions, but it can also leave viewers catching up. The competing recollections about how Picard got its title are amusing in the moment and hard to piece together afterward. The speakers firmly reject the rumor that a contract negotiation drove the Borg cliffhanger, then give an unverified story about cash arriving during a shoot room to linger. By the time the conversation follows Gregory Peck through several casting turns to Stewart’s King of Texas, the route to the payoff feels longer than it needs to be.

Pros

  • The recreated bridge gives the cast reunion a sense of place through details the people who worked there still remember.
  • The casting recollections explain why Stewart’s supporters felt he could give Picard the authority the role needed.
  • The actors’ disagreement over the car scene gives the tribute room for honest criticism of the work.
  • The front-row Macbeth story gets its humor from the storyteller’s embarrassment and Stewart’s timing.
  • The dinner and phone-call anecdotes convey Stewart’s friendships through specific moments his colleagues remember.

Cons

  • The speakers move through some theater memories so quickly that their praise leaves little sense of what Stewart did in the performance.
  • The overlapping accounts of how Picard got its title are difficult to follow.
  • The story about a cash payment on location goes unresolved after one participant says he had never heard it.
  • The closing chain of casting anecdotes takes a long time to reach Stewart’s turn as Lear.

The conversation has the warmth of colleagues who still enjoy making each other laugh and still have opinions about the scenes they made together. Its loose structure occasionally asks too much of the viewer, but the affection feels earned because the speakers remember Stewart in such particular ways.

Related Reviews