Saving Philadelphia One Safe Zone at a Time

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating7.8/10
Finally a Zombie game where the military is competent

A walled enclosure with a couple of gates and a handful of garrisons is enough to get the first rescue underway in Zombies Aren’t Real. Seven rounds on a custom Philadelphia map turn that modest setup into a citywide evacuation, with more territory opening after each round. The host establishes the right measure of success early. The military can clear the streets, but the percentage of civilians still alive tells you whether the defense worked.

Philadelphia gives the run a personality that a generic city map would struggle to match. The host builds around City Hall, reads the waterways as natural boundaries, and discovers how easily an overlooked crossing can undo a plan. His familiarity with the city makes the expanding map easier to follow. It also gives the later decision to concentrate on one corner of the map a sense of loss, since the audience has already seen him try to hold those neighborhoods.

The clearest lessons come from failures the host can explain as they happen. A gate-free enclosure accidentally redirects civilians toward an accessible safe zone, while a breach elsewhere leaves nearby units running through their remaining ammunition. That supply problem makes a much stronger case for the game’s depth than the enormous kill totals do. A defense can look secure right up until the guns fall quiet.

The commentary has an easy sense of humor, especially when the host discovers that a sufficiently large pond can hold a fleet of battleships. The nuclear fallback pays off the opening tease with a dark joke at his own expense. As the rounds grow more chaotic, though, the constant swings between confidence and alarm start to sound alike, and several late attempts spend too long following positions that are already collapsing.

Some of that confusion fits a live playthrough of an early-access game, but the running commentary leaves a few consequential details unresolved. The host is unsure what the yellow mutations do and whether the kill counter includes civilians. He also sets out to show off an unusually large imported map, and the reported lag spikes are worth flagging for anyone tempted to try it. One interrupts entry into the final round and forces him to go back in.

The final 10 percent rescue earns a bronze badge, a satisfyingly modest result after so many overconfident plans. The host credits helicopters and firebombs for the turnaround and acknowledges that skipping the nuclear strike helped. That gives the challenge a clear ending, although the successful attempt goes by so quickly that viewers get a better look at several failed layouts than at the one that finally holds.

Pros

  • The expanding map turns a simple rescue into a challenge with visibly changing priorities.
  • Familiar Philadelphia landmarks give viewers a way to follow the host’s decisions as the playable area grows.
  • The breached safe zones make the link between civilian protection and ammunition supply easy to understand.
  • The host’s self-deprecating humor makes his biggest mistakes some of the run’s most memorable moments.
  • The survival percentages give viewers a consistent way to judge each attempt even when the battlefield becomes hard to follow.

Cons

  • Several late retries linger on collapsing defenses after the outcome is already clear.
  • The commentary leaves the yellow mutations and the scope of the kill counter unexplained.
  • A lag spike interrupts the transition into the largest round and briefly stalls the escalation.
  • The winning retry gets too little time to show how its adjustments changed the outcome.

The Philadelphia challenge works because the host lets his mistakes reveal what the game asks of a player under pressure. The late retries could use tighter pacing, but a bronze finish feels earned in a run where getting even a fraction of the city out alive takes real improvisation.

Related Reviews