Seven TikTok Dishes and Only Three Chances to Eat

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating7.8/10
Smash or Pass: TikTok Chefs

A steak roll stuffed with avocado is already tempting, but the real pressure comes when the people who pass have to watch everyone else take a bite. Each panelist can choose only three of the seven featured dishes, and they make each decision before seeing what comes next. The game gets funnier as those choices narrow, especially when two panelists realize they’ve committed themselves to both remaining rounds.

The opening round makes a strong case for showing the original cooking clips before bringing out the plates. Bayashi’s ASMR gets the panel hungry before anyone tastes the beef, and the surprise steak burger from Albert Can Cook makes that first pass costlier than anyone expected. When a taster presses down on the towering burger and still struggles to fit the layers into one bite, the sheer size of the thing does more for the joke than any of the superlatives around it.

The creator profiles are most engaging when they explain why someone would make a particular dish. The pizza segment shows a creator responding to food-waste clips by remaking the food in quantity and sharing it. B. Dylan Hollis’s peanut butter bread offers a different reason to watch, with the discussion of inexpensive pantry staples giving the Great Depression recipe context. Exact view counts and long lists of celebrity collaborators take up time that could have gone toward more details like those.

The tasting gets more useful whenever someone describes what they’re actually eating. The torta draws specific praise for its sauce and heat, while the Ghanaian groundnut soup prompts an explanation of how the mashed rice ball is used to scoop it up. The cabbage rolls expose a drawback of the format. Only one panelist chooses them, so the audience gets plenty of second thoughts from the others and just one account of how the dish tastes.

The cabbage-roll segment also makes an awkward turn from the creator’s cooking and charitable work to her reported remarks about women’s freedoms. One panelist expresses interest in a more nuanced conversation, but the exchange offers little of the original interview’s context before moving back to the food. The subject could sustain a fuller discussion, and the quick detour leaves viewers with little basis for judging the remarks.

Everyone saves a choice for the Turkish meze spread, which gives the panel a rare chance to taste together and compare several dishes on one plate. The Atomic Wings bring back the bell for one last joke, and the tasters’ mixed reactions to the heat are funnier than their collective dread beforehand. The member shout-outs arrive just as the wings are about to be tasted, though, and interrupt the best moment of suspense in the closing stretch.

Pros

  • The three-choice limit gives early decisions consequences that pay off in later rounds.
  • The cooking clips let viewers see and hear what tempts the panel before the plates arrive.
  • The surprise steak burger turns an ordinary first-round pass into a memorable moment of regret.
  • The pizza and peanut butter bread profiles give viewers concrete reasons to care about the creators’ approaches.
  • Specific comments about the torta’s heat and the groundnut soup’s texture make the tasting more informative.

Cons

  • Repeated view counts and lengthy celebrity lists slow several of the creator introductions.
  • Rounds with only one taster leave little room for contrasting reactions to the food.
  • The discussion of the cabbage-roll creator’s reported remarks provides too little interview context to assess them fairly.
  • The member shout-outs interrupt the buildup to the Atomic Wings tasting.

The panel’s willingness to gamble on an unseen dish gives the meal a playful tension, and the menu has enough range to make those decisions interesting. The format works best when the tasters get specific about what’s on their plates, leaving viewers with a reason to seek out a dish they might otherwise have scrolled past.

Related Reviews