Shilo takes a bite of his Katz’s pastrami sandwich plain, reaches for a pickle, then tries Russian dressing and mustard. Mustard wins, and the soft bread gets some of his most enthusiastic praise. It’s a simple tasting sequence, but it gives his reaction to the towering sandwich more substance than a single bite and a letter grade would.
The counter service is nearly as memorable as the food. Shilo asks for the most popular order, gets sidetracked trying to figure out where to find a chopped cheese, and marvels at how quickly his order comes up. His view of the ingredients and preparation gives the visit a sense of place, while the questions he asks along the way capture what it’s like to walk in without knowing exactly what to order.
The cheesesteak gives Shilo a second sandwich to weigh against the pastrami, and his willingness to reconsider his first pick makes the tasting feel spontaneous. His descriptions grow less precise as he goes, though. Calling the cheesesteak distinctive gives an impression of his surprise, but he says little about what sets its flavor apart. The pastrami gets a more useful appraisal because he explains how the bread, pickles, and condiments change the bite.
Price becomes a running concern as Shilo takes stock of how much food he has ordered. The portion looks generous enough that he jokes about needing help to finish it, but the cost is harder to judge. An early exchange lands on $56, and he later says at the bakery that he spent $77 at Katz’s for two things. A breakdown of the bill would have helped viewers work out what to expect if they came for the pastrami alone.
Shilo has an easy rapport with the people around him, and a quick request for a fellow diner’s grade fits the casual tasting. The extended PrizePicks promotion that follows is a jarring shift. By the time he returns to the bill and wraps up at Katz’s, the review has lost the momentum of his back-and-forth over the sandwiches.
The walk to Sunday Morning turns the deli visit into a broader food outing. Sharing cinnamon rolls with his new companions brings out another side of Shilo’s hosting, especially when they disagree on their favorite and he gives the banana roll a 10 out of 10. The detour is personable, though the conversations about moving and meeting a partner stretch the ending well beyond the sandwich that brought him there.
Pros
- Trying the pastrami plain and with two condiments gives viewers a clear sense of how Shilo arrived at his preferred bite.
- The counter exchanges capture the pace of ordering and the experience of figuring out the menu on a first visit.
- The soft bread and the sheer size of the sandwich give the tasting details viewers can picture.
- Shilo’s willingness to take another bite and reconsider his favorite keeps the comparison spontaneous.
- Sharing the cinnamon rolls adds other palates and gives the second stop an easy social rhythm.
Cons
- The cheesesteak’s supposedly distinctive flavor gets little description beyond Shilo’s surprise.
- The two dollar figures go unexplained, making the cost of the featured sandwich difficult to gauge.
- The lengthy PrizePicks pitch breaks up the deli review just before its closing assessment.
- The neighborhood and relationship chatter draws out the bakery detour and dilutes the focus on Katz’s.
Shilo is an engaging first-time visitor whose curiosity makes the meal easy to follow, especially when he lets a second bite change his mind. The outing works better as a casual lunch with company than as a guide to what to order and what it will cost.


