SNL’s Carriage Driver Gives Central Park a Farewell Tour

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating7.6/10
Central Park Horse & Carriage Ride – SNL

A Central Park carriage driver insists there’s no reason to ban his trade, then casually names animal cruelty and murder. The line gets the sketch moving by letting the man make the case against himself before anyone can challenge him. The possible ban gives his tour the air of a farewell, and his affection for his horse gives the bombast a surprisingly tender edge.

The tourists are good foils because they’re almost as frank about the ride as the driver is about his profession. They want to see the park at walking speed while taking in the smell of horse manure, and he’s incredulous that anyone would trust a man with a top hat and a whip. That exchange gets more out of the premise than a simple clash between jaded locals and wide-eyed visitors would.

Once the carriage gets moving, the sketch turns its sightseeing stops into musical interruptions. A woman still finishing the marathon sings through her exhaustion, a funny mismatch between the grandeur of a solo and the modest goal of making it home. Some later encounters have less room to develop. The preacher whose delivery sounds more threatening than his message has a clear joke, but the sketch is already looking for its next attraction by the time it lands.

The pedicab rivalry is the best use of the musical format. A supposed John Henry-style showdown becomes a contest over which driver can hit people harder, ignore more rules, and cause more trouble. The competitive rhythm gives each boast somewhere to go, and the pedicab’s claim that it will have no natural predators once the carriages disappear makes the rivalry sound like a problem the city has been keeping in balance by accident.

The tour gets more uneven as it takes in Manhattan’s supposed cloud of weed and then turns to mayoral politics. The rent-freeze lyric gives the mayor’s supporter a concrete reason to sing, while the furious billionaire is a broader caricature. The rapid introductions leave some of the political humor dependent on viewers already knowing the local references, even though the earlier jokes about tourists and traffic explain themselves in a line or two.

The tourists’ decision to retreat to New Jersey gives the sketch a reason to bring the ride to a close, and the driver’s excuse about owing child support in Hoboken is a sharp last glimpse of his character. Personifying the Lincoln Tunnel squeezes another joke out of the attempted escape. By then, though, the driver’s early suggestion that this might be his last ride with his horse has lost some of its pull amid all the new arrivals.

Pros

  • The driver undermines his own defense of carriage rides in the opening exchange.
  • The tourists’ deadpan enthusiasm for an unglamorous ride makes them funny foils for the driver.
  • The exhausted marathon runner makes good comic use of a grand musical solo.
  • The pedicab duet builds its laughs by turning reckless behavior into a point of professional pride.
  • The Hoboken child-support line brings the driver’s personal shortcomings back into the joke at just the right moment.

Cons

  • Brief encounters such as the preacher’s end before the characters can build on their opening joke.
  • The Manhattan weed-cloud bit gets less mileage out of its premise than the more specific jokes about getting around the city.
  • The rush through the mayoral cameos gives viewers unfamiliar with local politics little time to place the references.
  • The accumulation of late cameos weakens the payoff to the driver’s possible last ride with his horse.

The sketch is funniest when people who make a living moving New Yorkers around sing as though the city owes them a standing ovation. The carriage driver gives that idea enough personality to carry a tour whose stops vary considerably in comic payoff.