An hour in a colander gives this apple pie two things the host wants: a filling that carries less liquid into the crust and a spiced juice worth saving. The apples turn glossy after they’re tossed with sugar and salt, and the amount of liquid they release makes the case for letting them sit. Reducing that juice into a glaze for the baked lattice is the recipe’s smartest touch. The host makes a step that could feel like an extra chore pay off in the finished pie.
The filling starts with Granny Smith and Honeycrisp apples, which the host chooses for their different textures as well as their tartness and sweetness. Asking viewers to taste both before deciding on the balance makes more sense than assuming every batch will behave alike. The advice on slicing is similarly flexible. The wedges need enough thickness to hold some shape, and a little variation is welcome. That flexibility is harder to apply when the sugar goes in by the handful and the cornstarch gets only a quick sprinkle, leaving a first-time baker to guess at the starting proportions.
The pastry demonstration is clearest when the host describes what to look and feel for. The butter and flour should resemble breadcrumbs before the water goes in, and the mixing stops once the dough starts coming together. Rolling outward from the center gives the viewer a motion to copy, while lifting the dough on parchment makes the transfer into the tin feel manageable. Returning the pieces to the refrigerator throughout the assembly reinforces the instruction to keep the dough cold.
There’s a welcome bit of honesty when the host admits that at home they’d probably tip the apples in and press them down. The careful layering still earns its place because the host explains what the extra work buys: fewer gaps and a fuller cross-section after the apples settle. The lattice gets an equally practical explanation. Alternating between lifting three strips and lifting the other two turns a decorative finish into a sequence that’s easy to follow.
The egg wash and sugar get specific explanations for the shine and crunch they’re meant to bring to the top, which makes the lack of oven guidance particularly noticeable. The host urges viewers to watch for burning, but gives neither a temperature nor an approximate baking time. The suggested three to four hours of cooling is useful for planning, though the quick move to the tasting leaves it unclear how long this pie actually rested.
The cheddar tasting is an enjoyable finish on its own. The host’s surprise feels genuine, and the comparison to salted caramel explains what they enjoy about the sweet and salty pairing. Repeated hints about a shocking reveal make a small serving experiment carry more suspense than it needs, especially when watching the drained juice become a glaze already gives the recipe a satisfying payoff.
Pros
- Tasting the apples before seasoning gives viewers a practical way to adjust the balance of tartness and sweetness.
- Draining the filling and reducing the collected juice connects a moisture-control step to the finished glaze.
- The dough’s visual cues and the parchment-assisted transfer make the pastry work easier to follow.
- The host explains what careful layering does for the slice and acknowledges the shortcut they would use at home.
- The alternating folds make the lattice pattern easy to reproduce.
- The cheddar tasting ends with a specific explanation of why the pairing works for the host.
Cons
- Imprecise quantities leave first-time bakers guessing about the proportions of the dough and filling.
- The oven sequence gives no temperature or approximate baking time.
- The tasting leaves it unclear whether the pie rested for the suggested three to four hours.
- Repeated teasers interrupt the preparation and build up a modest serving suggestion.
The host makes a lattice-topped pie feel approachable by showing where care pays off and where a shortcut is good enough for a homemade dessert. The missing measurements and oven settings limit its usefulness as a recipe to bake from, but the demonstration offers plenty to borrow for a pie you already know how to make.












