Trixie and Katya Size Up the Meanest Kids in Prep School

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating8.0/10
Drag Queens Trixie & Katya React to Cruel Intentions | Netflix

Sebastian looks ready for a business meeting when he still has geometry to get to, and Cecile shows up in a Tweety Bird shirt while Kathryn dresses like an attorney. Trixie and Katya get an impressive amount of mileage out of that wardrobe gap. Their jokes about shoulder pads, tiny sunglasses, and teenagers dressed for court also explain how Cruel Intentions tells viewers who’s innocent and who’s already practiced at getting her way.

The hosts keep the movie’s schemes surprisingly easy to follow. Short recaps establish what Sebastian and Kathryn stand to gain from their wager, how Cecile and her cello teacher get drawn in, and why the journal matters at the funeral. Those resets are especially welcome after the bawdy opening, which takes a while to get to the movie. Once the story is underway, even viewers who have forgotten who’s using whom can pick up the thread.

Trixie and Katya are funniest when one of them spots a detail and the other keeps building on it. Kathryn’s oversized hat and glasses turn a park encounter into a stakeout, while the journal’s public circulation eventually has them imagining a campus littered with takeout menus and sandwich-shop napkins. Their chemistry is less effective when they circle back to the same jokes about Sebastian’s looks. The first few reactions establish the joke well enough that later returns yield little.

Their discussion of virginity gives the raunch a sharper purpose. The two question why teen movies of the era treated sex as a conquest or a deadline, an observation that gets directly at what makes the central wager so ugly. They also recognize coercion in Sebastian’s behavior, but the jokes about Cecile’s intelligence and childlike manner crowd out that observation when her storyline reaches its most uncomfortable scenes.

The comparisons to Dangerous Liaisons make the adaptation tangible. The hosts recall aristocrats in elaborate gowns and connect Kathryn’s exposure at the funeral to the public humiliation at the opera. Their suggestion that the movie could have taken a Romeo + Juliet approach and kept the older language opens an interesting question about what survives the move to a New York prep school. The conversation moves on before they can do much with it.

Sarah Michelle Gellar earns the rare pause in the running commentary. When Kathryn tells Sebastian he was a toy, the hosts stop to appreciate how thoroughly Gellar takes command of the room, down to her posture and the way she delivers the line. After so many jokes about teenagers acting decades older than they are, it’s satisfying to hear the pair recognize how well that poise serves Kathryn when she finally spells out what she’s done.

Pros

  • The wardrobe jokes pick up on how the film signals innocence, status, and control.
  • Brief plot recaps keep the overlapping schemes easy to follow.
  • Trixie and Katya build on each other’s observations with quick, inventive riffs.
  • The discussion of virginity questions the idea of sex as a deadline or a prize in teen movies.
  • The pause for Sarah Michelle Gellar gives a pivotal performance its due.

Cons

  • The opening banter delays the first substantial reaction to the movie.
  • Repeated jokes about Sebastian’s looks lose momentum as the story progresses.
  • The jokes about Cecile’s intelligence crowd out a more thoughtful response to coercion in her storyline.
  • The comparisons to Dangerous Liaisons raise questions about the adaptation that the hosts leave largely unexplored.

Trixie and Katya remember enough about the era to catch details a casual rewatch might miss, and they’re irreverent enough to make familiar scenes feel unpredictable again. The reaction is at its best when their jokes reveal how carefully the movie packages its cruelty as glamour.

Related Reviews