When the Mine Ran Buchans

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating8.0/10
The Oddest Town in Newfoundland, The Town of Buchans.

A leaky tap in a Buchans company house once meant calling the same employer that ran the mine. A former resident recalls that the company would send someone to fix it, just as it would send painters when a home needed work. That detail gives the town’s history a domestic scale. The same speaker remembers his father leaving fishing for a steady mining job, a family decision that gives the host’s fascination with this inland Newfoundland town a more persuasive footing than his sweeping claims about how unusual it is.

The resident’s account is particularly revealing about what the company provided and what the work demanded. He remembers company-funded sports and schools, down to the pencils, and credits summer jobs at the mine with helping students finish university without debt. His description of early miners working seven days a week, ten or twelve hours a day, sits uneasily alongside those fond memories. The video could have spent more time with that tension, especially when it moves from the sale of company housing to the mine’s closure in 1984 with little explanation of what happened to those jobs and services.

At the old mine site, the host’s curiosity gives the industrial remains some personality. He picks out quartz among the core samples, marvels at the size of the headframe, and pauses over the bearing on a piece of machinery he takes to be a crusher. A historical photograph helps viewers picture how much more once stood around the headframe. The explanations vary in reliability. The host readily admits that he is guessing about several pieces of equipment, yet delivers a story about the origin of “balls to the wall” with more certainty than the visit can support.

The ride through town makes the changes since the mining years easier to grasp. The former resident misses having restaurants, and the host passes the old Community Mart, where books and VHS tapes are still on the shelves beneath a collapsed roof. The current grocery store and fuel station sit next door, and the host has already shopped there. That adjacency says more about daily life in present-day Buchans than another pass by an abandoned building would have.

The backroad map explains how Buchans became a stop on a crossing from Badger toward Highway 480. The detour through Millertown has a connection to the history of the area. The host explains that the dam raised the lake and says some of the town had to move to higher ground. His account of relics that may surface at low water adds an intriguing possibility to the stop, though the visit ends with that history largely unexplored.

The weather gives the road trip a story of its own. An unexpected snowfall turns the drive into a slow crawl, and by morning the water pooled on the boat cover has frozen. The host’s pleasure in the clear day that follows keeps the sequence companionable, even as the long final stretch and a stop for spring water leave Buchans well behind. The closing miles work better as part of an ongoing travel series than as the ending to a profile of the town.

Pros

  • The resident’s family memories make the company town tangible through everyday details about work, housing, and school.
  • The account of company-funded education and summer employment gives viewers a concrete sense of how the mine influenced opportunities beyond mining.
  • The historical photograph gives the surviving headframe context within the former mine complex.
  • The visit to the old Community Mart and its operating neighbor captures a change in town life in a single stop.
  • The sudden snowfall and clear morning give the backroad crossing a convincing sense of place.

Cons

  • The opening claim about Buchans’ uniqueness gets little comparison with other Newfoundland towns.
  • The mine’s closure receives too little attention given how deeply the company was involved in local life.
  • The explanation of the engine governor slips into an unsupported claim about the origin of a familiar phrase.
  • The extended drive after Millertown weakens the focus on Buchans.

Buchans is worth the stop for the way one resident’s memories give the old mine a place in the life of a family. The visit leaves enough unanswered about the years after closure to make a longer conversation in town feel more inviting than the road out.

Recent Reviews