A Generator Rewind Turns Into an Engineering Investigation

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating8.5/10
Making A Custom Generator, Part 2. Rewinding The Stator.

Fitting 17-gauge magnet wire into a tightly packed 39-slot stator quickly proves that rewinding this generator is less about simply counting turns and more about solving a succession of mechanical and electrical problems. John needs 36 coils arranged across three phases, including wider coils that cross the stator’s three skipped slots, while targeting the voltage characteristics required by his 1,800 RPM hydro turbine. The project immediately feels like genuine experimental engineering because seemingly minor details—wire size, coil dimensions, insulation and even how neatly the conductors lie beside each other—can determine whether the finished generator works at all.

The early test windings are especially useful because failures remain part of the presentation rather than being edited away. John discovers a short after overlooking insulation in one of the previously unused slots, redesigns small 3D-printed clips when the first versions fail to hold the windings properly, and changes his winding technique to keep the wires flat enough to enter the narrow stator openings. These iterations make the process understandable while demonstrating why careful organization matters. His explanation of alternating coil direction also gives viewers an accessible picture of how neighboring magnetic poles can produce additive rather than opposing electrical output.

What initially appears to be a straightforward rewind then expands into a worthwhile investigation of generator losses. By driving the generator with a lathe, measuring power consumption with and without it attached, and comparing results across different speeds, John estimates roughly 150 watts of loss at 1,800 RPM. He appropriately treats that figure with skepticism rather than immediately accepting it, recognizing that the lathe, drive system and imperfect coupling could influence the measurement. Adding a Lovejoy coupling, conducting a 70-minute temperature test and testing the measurement setup against a known resistive load provide increasingly practical checks on the result.

The temperature experiment produces one of the more interesting complications. With the generator case eventually reaching about 155°F, John worries that internal temperatures may have weakened the permanent magnets after a later voltage test appears roughly five percent lower. The apparent failure turns out to be a measurement issue: two different multimeters produce different readings, and repeating the test with the original meter reproduces the earlier voltage. It is an excellent illustration of why consistent instrumentation matters, although the long diversion also shows how easily this kind of open-ended troubleshooting can consume the project.

Further testing of the wide and narrow coils adds another useful layer. By installing a center tap between the two test coils, John measures their contributions separately and finds that the narrower three-pitch coil produces slightly more voltage than the four-pitch version in his setup. He then uses those measurements, along with calculations attributed to his engineering collaborator, to settle on 17 turns per coil. Some of the electrical explanation remains dependent on that collaborator's calculations rather than being fully derived on screen, particularly the stated loading factor, but the measurements themselves make the design process much more transparent.

The final stretch turns into a demanding fabrication sequence as all three phases are wound and packed into the stator. Custom winding sticks, clips, wax, wooden tools, fish paper and Nomex insulation all emerge from practical problems encountered along the way. Running short of magnet wire forces an unwanted dry run, while insufficient clearance threatens the second and third phases until a wooden lever provides enough space. Continuity and resistance checks after each stage help establish that the increasingly aggressive manipulation has not obviously damaged the winding insulation.

By the time the third phase is installed, the project has delivered substantial progress without reaching the functioning-generator payoff originally intended. That makes the ending inherently incomplete: star wiring, enameling and final testing are postponed, and an unidentified future problem is teased for the next installment. Still, the unfinished state fits the methodical character of the project better than rushing through those steps would have. The combination of mistakes, measurements, revised tools and painstaking winding work makes this a detailed account of figuring out an unfamiliar engineering problem rather than merely demonstrating a polished solution.

Pros

  • Shows unsuccessful attempts and measurement errors alongside the successful work, making the development process unusually transparent.
  • Practical tests of voltage, resistance, temperature and power consumption provide useful evidence for major design decisions.
  • Custom clips, winding fixtures, insulation methods and wooden tools demonstrate creative solutions to the stator's physical constraints.
  • Explanations of coil direction, skipped slots and winding layout make a complicated rewind reasonably approachable.
  • Repeated continuity and resistance checks reinforce the importance of verifying the work throughout the process.

Cons

  • The lengthy investigation of core losses and possible magnet damage significantly delays the central stator-rewinding project.
  • Some electrical conclusions rely on calculations from the unnamed engineering collaborator without fully showing how those results were derived.
  • The generator remains unfinished, leaving its actual voltage, efficiency, temperature under electrical load and overall suitability unresolved.
  • Several long, repetitive winding sequences are necessary to document the difficulty but make the presentation more demanding than the underlying progress might suggest.

A deceptively difficult stator rewind becomes an engaging engineering experiment because each setback leads to another measurement, tool or refinement rather than an easy shortcut. Although the lack of a completed generator prevents the project from delivering its ultimate result, the careful troubleshooting and willingness to expose mistakes make the process valuable in its own right. The next stage still has considerable work to do before the design can be judged as a successful hydroelectric generator.

Related Reviews