Dane Cook Finds the Comedy in a Typing Indicator

Rating

Video Reviewed
Rating7.2/10
DANE COOK – TROUBLEMAKER (FULL SPECIAL)

Dane Cook asks the balcony to prove it’s ready by jumping, then tells the couples in the room that some of them will be leaving separately. The mock threat gives the special a premise it can return to whenever Cook wanders. Sometimes his relationship material takes a while to get where it’s going, as when he builds up an embrace at a crowded mall into a grand romantic gesture. The reveal that the boyfriend is simply trying to steer his partner through the crowd gets a laugh from the sudden change in motive, though Cook spends longer describing her insecurities than the reversal needs.

The opening detours show how much Cook depends on the turn at the end of a story. His concern about violent video games sounds almost earnest until he reveals which edition of Madden he’s supposedly playing. The joke makes good use of the audience member who boos the premise before hearing him out. The slow-line routine about hunger and racism has less going on beneath its provocation, and the baby back ribs bit stretches a single abortion pun through an entire restaurant exchange.

Cook is sharper when a small detail already carries some tension. A typing indicator in a text argument becomes a countdown, a stalled progress bar gives the sender one last moment to regret hitting send, and the disappearance of the three dots leaves him furious about a reply he never received. His shifts from panic to swagger and back give the scene its rhythm. The emoji catalog that follows is more uneven, although the imaginary design meeting about why the poop emoji needs eyes gives him an actual scene to play.

The social media routines gain something when Cook makes himself the fool. In the Soul Crusher 11 story, he covers for posting a goofy throwback photo to the wrong account by staging a public dispute between his two identities. Later, he compares checking an ex’s Facebook page to driving past their house at night. The detail that sells the comparison is his recognition of the hallway light. It captures how much meaning someone can wring from a glimpse when they’re looking for any sign of how an ex is doing.

The phone-snooping story goes further into that pettiness. Cook acts out a boyfriend’s escalating excuses for keeping his phone, then casts himself as the jealous partner who retaliates over a voicemail by deleting apps and rearranging icons. The missing phone icon gives his wounded pride a funny, specific outlet. Some of the later breakup material trades that specificity for familiar divisions between men and women, although the run-in with an ex earns its place by bringing back an insult from the text fight at precisely the wrong moment.

Cook’s rapport with the room can turn sour, as it does when he draws out his mockery of a spectator whose interjection he can barely hear. The closing anecdote is a better use of his taste for discomfort. A younger woman asks what year he graduated, and the ordinary question suddenly makes their age gap impossible to ignore. Cook gives the silence and awkward arithmetic enough room to work before making himself sound worse with the final line.

Pros

  • The opening promise to break up couples gives the set a recurring premise and makes the live audience part of it.
  • The Madden reveal rewards Cook’s patience in letting the setup sound like a sincere complaint.
  • The text argument turns the timing of familiar phone cues into a physical performance.
  • The Soul Crusher 11 mix-up and the missing phone icon make Cook’s own vanity and resentment funny.
  • The hallway light gives the comparison between a late-night drive-by and a Facebook visit an unusually precise detail.

Cons

  • The slow-line routine relies on racial stereotypes for a payoff the setup does little to complicate.
  • The baby back ribs and emoji stretches keep adding examples after their premises are clear.
  • Broad claims about how men and women behave make several relationship and breakup routines predictable.
  • The prolonged mockery of a spectator stalls the set and wears out the initial interruption.

Cook gets the most out of a combustible premise when he lets his own character unravel in front of the audience. There’s enough precision in those moments to carry the special through its looser stretches, even as some of the provocations wear thin well before he moves on.

Related Reviews