Michelle has to leave part of Gengar attached to the pumpkin so the character can appear to float without falling out. That small compromise gets at what makes the $1,000 contest fun to watch. Four contestants start with the same basic material, but each has to figure out what a thick, awkward pumpkin will let them do.
The early carving gives each entry a distinct problem to solve. Michelle cuts away the space around Gengar and Gastly, while Jake and David carve deep into their pumpkins to give a Pennywise face and a piranha head more dimension. Francine, a first-time carver, abandons a fur-heavy Gizmo design for Derpy Tiger once she realizes how much detail she would have to finish. Zach’s check-ins help viewers understand those choices, especially when he asks Jake how he’ll restore Pennywise’s red streaks after cutting away the skin.
The blindfolded scavenger hunt is the best of the side games because its outcome changes the work at the table. Michelle spends half an hour trying to make progress with plastic utensils, while Jake and David recruit each other to make teeth for their competing monsters. There’s a similarly funny reversal when Jake earns the right to gouge a rival pumpkin and picks a spot Michelle already meant to cut away. The later pumpkin toss earns its place too, since every extra five minutes matters to someone still fitting or painting teeth.
Other detours are harder to justify. Pumpkin bowling takes a while to settle who gets a bonus bet and who has to wear a costume, and the jokes about how the costumes smell outlast the initial gag. The crochet-kit skit is an even bigger interruption, arriving just as David is reconsidering his fish design and Michelle is finding out how much deeper she has to carve.
Putting a light inside each finished pumpkin pays off decisions that were easy to underestimate while the contestants worked. David’s pinpricks become glowing spots across the piranha’s scales, and Pennywise’s bright eyes draw attention above the rows of teeth. Francine gets the most satisfying surprise. After worrying that her tiger would look crude beside the others, she gets a soft gradient from carving away material on the inside, giving her entry a character of its own.
Zach explains his initial picks with enough detail to make them worth hearing, praising the clean cuts on Michelle’s design and favoring Jake’s teeth and eyes over David’s. The closing tally is harder to follow. Zach gives his favorites two points and one point, then describes the target as five votes. The subsequent voting comes in a rush, and the contest ends without clearly announcing who reached the threshold and took home the $1,000.
Pros
- The four designs give viewers distinctly different approaches to carving and lighting a pumpkin.
- Zach’s progress checks make the artists’ decisions about depth, shape, and remaining time easy to follow.
- The blindfolded hunt produces a funny exchange of labor between two direct rivals.
- The final pumpkin toss makes extra carving time feel genuinely valuable.
- The lit reveals give details like the piranha’s scales and Francine’s softly shaded tiger a satisfying payoff.
Cons
- The bowling sequence spends too much time sorting out the tie and its consequences.
- The costume jokes keep going after the initial reactions have landed.
- The extended crochet-kit promotion interrupts the carving at a point when several designs are taking shape.
- The shift from points to votes and the rushed closing tally leave the prize outcome unclear.
The fun here is watching four people discover what their pumpkins can become under a deadline. By the time the lights go in, there’s a good case for more than one favorite, which makes the hurried finish especially frustrating.


