A blonde wig, exaggerated blush and a carefully placed lipstick mark turn the Sabrina Carpenter recreation into an immediate test of how much detail is necessary to make an imitation recognizable. The process is deliberately homemade rather than polished, with Bailey trimming bangs, layering makeup and searching for a suitably blue-sky background while everyone debates tiny differences in pose and styling. That casual problem-solving establishes the format well: accuracy matters, but the awkwardness of getting there is where much of the entertainment comes from.
The Justin Bieber recreation pushes that approach further, particularly when Brooklyn swaps her normal contacts for brown ones despite being unable to see properly afterward. The wig, vest, chain and intense camera stare give the group several recognizable visual elements to work with, while the running disagreement about Bieber's hair color supplies an amusingly trivial argument. There is an appealing willingness to commit to unnecessary details simply because they might make the final image slightly closer.
Recreating the Beatles' Abbey Road cover expands the concept beyond a single-person transformation and gives the supporting crew a chance to participate. Costumes, wigs, a homemade pretend cigarette and carefully coordinated walking positions all contribute to the attempt, while the absence of the original road markings and other background elements is openly left for later photo editing. That reliance on post-production means the photographed setup itself is less ambitious than it could be, but coordinating four people introduces a welcome change from the portrait recreations.
The Demi Lovato attempt returns to costume-driven imitation with leather clothing, improvised side bangs and a red guitar. Here, the repeated adjustments to arm placement, shoulders and facial angle demonstrate how deceptively difficult it can be to copy a seemingly straightforward photograph. The segment also benefits from Brooklyn's self-deprecating reactions to the clothing and styling, keeping what could have become a repetitive sequence of pose corrections light and personable.
The Miley Cyrus recreation leans even harder into small visual details, from blue-toned earrings and brown eyeshadow to concealer being used to disguise colorful nails. There is something inherently funny about putting that much effort into features viewers might barely notice, and the group understands that absurdity. At the same time, the video's middle stretch develops a predictable rhythm of outfit, wig, makeup, pose and correction, so the format loses some freshness despite the changing artists.
The Olivia Rodrigo recreation provides a strong finish because the sticker-covered face creates a particularly distinctive challenge. Considerable attention goes into approximating the sticker placement, hair position, tongue pose, head angle and exposure, and the participants appear genuinely pleased when the photograph comes together. Holding the completed results until the end gives the preparation a payoff, although the closing subscription request briefly interrupts that momentum before the reveal.
Pros
- The recreations use recognizable, artist-specific details rather than relying only on costumes.
- Wig, makeup, posing and prop mishaps generate natural humor throughout the process.
- The Abbey Road recreation adds welcome variety by involving a larger group and a different photographic setup.
- Frequent comparisons with the target poses show how much attention goes into seemingly minor details.
- The Olivia Rodrigo recreation gives the sequence a visually distinctive final challenge.
Cons
- Several individual recreations follow essentially the same outfit-makeup-wig-pose structure, making the middle portion repetitive.
- Reliance on later photo editing, particularly for the Abbey Road setting and album-cover text, reduces some of the challenge of recreating everything practically.
- Some prolonged discussions over hair, makeup and posing could be tightened without sacrificing the personality of the process.
- The subscription appeal immediately before the results delays the payoff the video has spent its runtime building toward.
Careful visual imitation and knowingly improvised solutions make these album-cover recreations more entertaining as a behind-the-scenes challenge than as a simple before-and-after showcase. The formula becomes repetitive across six attempts, but the personalities, small styling details and satisfying final comparisons give the concept enough variety to remain enjoyable.












