The heavier Audi RS5 repeatedly gets ahead off the line, only for the RS6 GT to reel it in. That pattern gives Matt Watson and Nick something more interesting to discuss than which Audi wins. The opening comparison sets up the surprise neatly. The RS5’s twin-turbo V6 and electric motor combine for a quoted 639 horsepower in a car weighing 2.4 tonnes, while the RS6 GT’s twin-turbo V8 makes 630 horsepower and has roughly 300 kilograms less to carry.
An early run goes awry when Watson expects the RS5 to upshift out of manual mode and hits the limiter. Having Nick try the behavior in the RS6 GT helps explain the mistake, and the cleaner runs that follow establish a consistent pattern. Watson reports quarter-mile times of 11.5 seconds for the RS6 GT and 11.7 for the RS5, with the RS6 GT recording a best of 11.3 seconds without passengers. Those numbers give the rivalry some scale after all the shouting over the radio.
Putting passengers in the RS6 GT is a playful way to see whether adding weight can bring the cars closer together. The RS5 finally holds off the fully loaded Audi on one run, and removing passengers eventually restores the V8 car’s advantage. The segment also swaps drivers, leaves the actual passenger weight unreported, and includes uneven starts and a jump. It makes for a lively demonstration, though the changes make it difficult to pin down how much of the difference came from the extra weight.
The rolling races are better structured. A 50 mph start in Comfort with both gearboxes in automatic gives the drivers a plausible overtaking setup, and switching to sportier settings gives the RS5 a better chance to show its response. The 10 mph first-gear run makes that response especially clear. The hybrid pulls away early enough for Watson to joke that he wins at legal road speeds, while the RS6 GT closes the gap once the pace builds.
The braking test gives both drivers a chance to describe how the cars feel under a hard stop, with each reporting some movement. The presenters treat the RS6 GT’s shorter stop as further evidence of the weight penalty, but they give no stopping distances or repeat runs. That leaves the audience with a finishing order and two useful impressions from behind the wheel, while the explanation gets more certainty than the test can support.
Watson and Nick are funniest when the teasing comes straight from the race, particularly when a confident prediction falls apart seconds after the launch. The mock protests and drawn-out forfeits slow the passenger experiment once its basic point is clear. The closing preference for the V8 fits the tone, though the standing and rolling starts give the RS5’s hybrid system a more interesting showing than the repeated jokes about its weight suggest.
Pros
- The opening specifications establish why two Audis with similar horsepower can behave differently.
- Asking Nick to test the manual-mode shifting makes sense of the spoiled opening run.
- The quarter-mile times give the audience a concrete measure of how close the cars are.
- Adding and removing passengers turns the weight discussion into an entertaining on-track experiment.
- The rolling starts show how speed, gear selection, and drive mode change the initial response.
Cons
- The passenger experiment leaves the added weight unreported and changes drivers and launch quality across the comparison.
- The braking segment draws a confident conclusion from a single stop without giving measured distances.
- The mock protests and forfeits stretch the middle of the video.
- The closing verdict gives little weight to the hybrid’s demonstrated advantage at lower speeds.
The matchup works because the car that feels quickest at the start keeps giving the eventual winner something to chase. Watson and the crew make that difference easy to see, even when the jokes and improvised rematches get in the way of explaining it. It’s an entertaining head-to-head whose results are more persuasive than its broader verdict on hybrid performance.

