A twenty-sided die decides which Mad Libs pages will become stand-up material at an open mic. The performers gather words without seeing the finished stories, then have to read the results to strangers. Keeping the premise from the room is the best decision the group makes. A story that sounds ridiculous among friends has a different kind of tension when it’s introduced as new material at My Father’s Place.
The writing session is funniest when a basic grammar prompt turns into a negotiation. Pikachu gets rejected as a proper noun, while two full-frame copies of Ratatouille on DVD somehow make it through. The difference between those answers gives the banter some shape, especially when the person taking dictation sounds more exhausted than amused. That part of the challenge runs long, though, and some of the word lists have worn out their jokes by the time the performers leave for the venue.
Introduced as Darren Branson, the first performer reads a set of holiday survival tips for dealing with the in-laws. The brisk opening and little asides about which lines he expected to land give the impression of a comic trying to rescue a routine one sentence at a time. There’s a good payoff when he revisits the earlier argument over whether the plural should be “Captain’s America.” The longer Marvel answers are harder to sell, particularly when the Ant-Man and Thanos digression interrupts a sentence that already needs help getting to its point.
Chuck Lunch takes the opposite tack, introducing his ghost story with mock sincerity and reading it as though every sentence makes perfect sense. The invented piss badger is a better payoff than most of the recycled answers because the haunted-house story gives it something to do. By the time a giant white one floats through the door, the performer has managed to give a word invented on the spot a recognizable role in the story.
Putting the two sets together shows what the underlying templates contribute. The in-law advice restarts with each new tip, so a clumsy substitution can stop a joke without giving the next one much momentum. The ghost story has a noise, a presence and a reveal, so it keeps moving even when the same word stands in for a drink, a book and a room. Both sets go back to crude humor often enough that some of the substitutions are easy to anticipate.
After the performances, the group jokes about whether they made anyone laugh and wraps up. The quick exit suits the awkwardness of the stunt, but it leaves the performers’ expectations from the writing session hanging. A brief exchange about which lines surprised them onstage would have given that setup a fuller payoff.
Pros
- Keeping the premise from the open-mic audience gives the readings genuine stakes.
- The arguments over parts of speech make the writing session entertaining in its own right.
- Darren’s asides turn his visible struggle with the material into part of the act.
- The return to “Captain’s America” rewards viewers who followed the preparation.
- Chuck’s earnest delivery carries the ghost story all the way to its absurd apparition.
Cons
- Several rounds of word gathering keep the setup going after the joke has landed.
- The longest Marvel substitutions break the rhythm of the in-law routine.
- The reliance on bodily humor makes some answers predictable in a game built around surprise.
- The quick sign-off gives the performers little time to reflect on how the sets played in the room.
There’s more pleasure in watching the performers commit to their bad material than in hearing most of the completed jokes. The two sets are uneven, but taking them to a real open mic gives the group’s familiar banter a consequence worth sticking around for.












