Grand Theft Auto VI has a Game of the Year nomination before its public release, as the host and several commenters point out during the 2026 Game Awards reveal. He predicts it will win and argues that it should have been considered the following year, when players could judge it for themselves. With his own favorite, Crimson Desert, missing from the ballot, the reveal gives him two reasons to question the shortlist. The timing objection has wider relevance than his personal pick, although the reaction leaves the award’s eligibility rules unexplored.
The host makes a sharper case when he explains what an individual award should reward. He calls Phantom Blade Zero an excellent action game while questioning what it does to expand the genre, then makes his case for Pragmata by describing the puzzles it asks players to solve during combat. He also singles out the moon base and the pictures Diana gives the player, details that show how much of his appreciation comes from choices outside combat. That specificity gives viewers something to weigh when he declares a favorite.
His choices for community support and best independent game reveal how experience shapes his ballot. For Crimson Desert, he points to how quickly the developers responded to feedback and added features players wanted, then acknowledges that he knows less about Warframe and No Man’s Sky. His preference for Mina the Hollower comes with a similarly candid admission that he was tired of roguelites when Mugenics came out. He still entertains the idea that Mugenics deserves the award for breaking through, a moment when the live chat helps him test his own judgment.
Ocarina of Time’s nominations prompt the most concrete proposal for changing the show. The host would give remakes their own category, and his preference for Control Resonant’s visual framing gives that debate an example beyond nostalgia for Zelda. When chat asks how he would define a remake, though, the discussion stalls. His willingness to treat the Final Fantasy VII projects differently raises a question his proposal needs to answer about how extensively a game can be reworked before it belongs alongside original releases.
The player-count comparisons give his frustration over Palworld’s absence more substance. Pulling up the figures lets him show why a second surge around the full release impressed him, and he uses similar comparisons to put 007 First Light’s reach in perspective. Those numbers speak to audience turnout. His further suggestion that months of promotion manufactured enthusiasm for 007 rests largely on his impression of the marketing, and the comments he reads aloud provide little basis for judging how widespread the discontent is.
The live format catches the host changing his mind and admitting when he has skipped a nominee, which makes the discussion feel open to challenge. It also leaves in repeated returns to the same snubs and quick dismissals of entire categories. The speculation that a creator was nominated to fill a quota is especially weak because it follows directly from the host saying he has never heard of her. Moments like that make the reveal less informative just when the unfamiliar names give him the most room to ask what the jury saw in them.
Pros
- The discussion of GTA VI’s nomination raises a concrete question about how viewers can assess a contender before its public release.
- The comparison between Pragmata and Phantom Blade Zero gives the Best Game Direction debate a specific design criterion.
- The case for Crimson Desert ties community support to the speed and substance of the developer’s response to players.
- The host’s candor about roguelite fatigue gives viewers context for his preference for Mina the Hollower.
- The player-count comparison gives the argument for recognizing Palworld a measurable basis.
Cons
- The host leaves the eligibility rules unexplored even as GTA VI’s nomination becomes the central dispute.
- The proposed remake category loses precision when chat asks where substantial reimaginings would fit.
- The claims about manufactured enthusiasm for 007 First Light and quota-filling in the creator category assign motives on thin evidence.
- Repeated complaints about the same omissions and abrupt dismissals of whole categories make the reaction uneven.
- The selection of chat and comment reactions provides little sense of how widely the host’s objections are shared.
The reveal works best as an argument over what the trophies should reward, especially when the host can point to a design choice or a developer’s response to players. His willingness to reconsider a pick gives the reaction some range, but the accusations carry more certainty than the discussion earns. It makes for a lively watch with an uneven case against the ballot.












