A running gag about screaming goats carries more weight in this essay than any of Taika Waititi’s celebrity endorsements. The narrator pairs Thor: Ragnarok, where he argues that the comedy gives the characters room to breathe, with Thor: Love and Thunder, where the barrage of gags crowds a story about Jane’s cancer and a villain bent on killing gods. Comparing two films about the same hero makes the criticism easy to follow. The narrator is listening for when a joke lands and what gets lost when it arrives.
The opening sets that comparison against a longer history of watching Waititi in New Zealand. The narrator remembers being disappointed by Eagle vs Shark, laughing through What We Do in the Shadows in the Wellington cinema that appears in the film, and attending a Q&A for Hunt for the Wilderpeople. Those details give his affection for the earlier work some texture. The reference to Tall Poppy Syndrome also gives the essay a question worth sitting with. How much of the backlash comes from the films themselves, and how much comes from the pleasure people take in seeing a conspicuously successful figure stumble?
The later films get uneven treatment. Next Goal Wins offers a useful test of the essay’s argument because its smaller scale and Polynesian setting are closer to the kind of material the narrator once admired in Waititi’s work. Calling it flat and invoking Cool Runnings gives a sense of the missed opportunity, though a scene or two would have made the judgment more persuasive. With Klara and the Sun, the narrator acknowledges that he hasn’t read the novel and that the audience score is respectable. His account of what the adaptation loses therefore depends heavily on other critics’ readings.
Chelsea Winstanley receives more careful attention than the online theory about her influence might suggest. The essay narrows her formal producing role in Waititi’s filmography to two films, makes room for her work in Māori-language film and documentary, and lets her describe how she experienced the unraveling of the marriage. The narrator then calls the loss of her creative perspective the biggest factor in Waititi’s change as a filmmaker. Her account has real weight as testimony about the relationship. The essay has considerably less to show about her influence on particular scripts or how that influence changed after the separation.
The other explanations, celebrity and overwork, run into a similar gap. The essay has something concrete to discuss in Waititi’s public reaction to critics, and the passage it cites situates those remarks within a wider culture of celebrity coverage. The discussion of brand deals and appearances with Rita Ora is less revealing about decisions made on a film set. The sheer range of Waititi’s commitments makes divided attention plausible, but the essay infers how much attention he gave Next Goal Wins largely from how the finished film feels.
The closing section regains some of the opening’s generosity. The narrator sees a possible route back through material suited to Waititi’s comic instincts, whether that means an outright comedy in the vein of What We Do in the Shadows or another story grounded in New Zealand. The two possibilities give the ending more range than a plea to recreate an earlier career. They also bring the discussion back to a question the films themselves can help answer about which stories give Waititi’s style room to work.
Pros
- The comparison between the two Thor films shows how the placement and frequency of jokes can change the stakes of a scene.
- The narrator’s memories of watching Waititi’s early films in New Zealand give his appraisal a clear personal and cultural perspective.
- The discussion of Chelsea Winstanley corrects an exaggerated account of her producing credits and recognizes her career in her own right.
- The quoted response to Waititi’s remarks about critics broadens the discussion to the celebrity media environment around him.
- The ending considers several kinds of material that could suit Waititi’s comic instincts.
Cons
- The discussion of Next Goal Wins gives few concrete examples of where the comedy or character work falls flat.
- The assessment of what Klara and the Sun loses in adaptation leans heavily on other critics’ judgments.
- The essay assigns the divorce a level of creative significance that Winstanley’s account of the relationship cannot establish.
- The speculation about celebrity and workload relies on public behavior and impressions of finished films to infer what happened during production.
There’s an engaging film essay here about how a director can keep his comic instincts and lose some of his judgment about when to use them. The career diagnosis is shakier, but the narrator’s affection for Waititi’s work gives his disappointment a specificity that the usual celebrity backlash rarely has.












